Originally published by evpowered.co.uk. By Matt Allan.

The UK will miss its legally binding climate targets and throw away a chance to reduce living costs if it softens the ZEV Mandate target on EV sales, according to the country’s independent climate advisor.

Nigel Topping, chair of the Climate Change Committee (CCC), has written to Transport Secretary Heidi Alexander warning that any change to the mandate brings economic and energy security risks, including missing targets, harming the UK car industry and leaving households exposed to volatile oil prices.

In his letter, he says the committee believes the mandate is “working effectively” and market growth for EVs is ahead of the level required to meet the 2030 target.

He points to “flexibilities” in CO2 allowances, which he says have worked as intended and mean manufacturers need to achieve EV sales of around 25% to meet their obligations this year against a stated target of 33%. In October, EVs accounted for 26.6% of the new car market.

Under the current ZEV Mandate, EV sales must account for 38% of sales in 2027, rising to 80% in 2030. The UK car industry has campaigned heavily for these targets to be reduced, claiming they are forcing “unsustainable” discounting and threatening the long-term future of the industry.

The Government has carried out a consultation on the targets and is expected to publish its findings soon.

Missed targets and damaged industry

Topping says that cutting targets would leave the UK dependent on up to 15 billion barrels of oil per year by 2030, costing the UK more than £1bn and exposing households to volatile price changes. He also claims drivers not switching to EVs could lose out on running cost reductions of £800 per year.

Advertisement

He also points to the Government’s own studies, which suggest cutting the headline targets in the mandate would reduce emissions savings so much that the UK would miss its legally binding Sixth Carbon Budget target.

And he says that uncertainties jeopardise investment and competitiveness in the UK car market just as it is needed most.

He notes: “In the EU, the UK’s largest export market, EV sales have now overtaken petrol cars. Germany (37% market share in October) and France (41%) have recently overtaken the UK in EV adoption and the UK now ranks 22nd globally for EV sales share over the last 12 months. The certainty provided by the mandate has underpinned investment worth billions of pounds in vehicle and battery manufacturing, charging, and critical minerals.”

Along with recommending sticking to the headline 2030 target, the CCC also calls for tougher rules on plug-in hybrids. It says that data shows they are far more polluting and use far more fuel than tests suggest. It also says that using the current “artificially high” baseline based on 2021 emissions data is “effectively subsidising Chinese PHEVs”.

Weakened mandate would be a backward step

Vicky Edmonds, CEO of drivers’ body EVA England, said the Government must hold firm on its targets and work to make EVs more affordable and accessible for all.

She commented: “The Climate Change Committee is right: weakening the ZEV mandate would be a backwards step. The endless wrangling over targets is distracting from what really matters, and that is getting more people into electric cars.”

Matt Galvin, UK managing director of all-electric brand Polestar said the mandate was “fundamental” to a transition away from harmful transport emissions, with the country at a tipping point.

He said: “There is room to debate the pace of the transition, but there must be no retreat from the destination. Moving the goalposts dramatically at this stage would undermine investor confidence, penalise manufacturers that have committed to electrification and leave British drivers with fewer models, less choice, and potentially higher prices. The industry needs long-term certainty to invest, innovate and compete. My message to ministers is simple: progress, not postponement.”