Embark Studios has apologized for replacing human casters’ voices with AI in a recap video for The Finals esports tournament, and has taken down the video after criticism from casters and fans.

The video featured highlights from the APAC Closed Qualifiers for The Grand Major, Embark’s annual championship tournament for its team-based FPS. The original commentary was by human casters, but the recap used voices from the game’s AI commentators, Scotty and June.

The decision drew criticism from casters ProtoANZ and Bluepanda. ProtoANZ wrote on X: "After 4 cycles, open/closed quals, the time, effort, passion and emotion myself @TheeHyperactive and @bluepanda_casts put in," followed by, "We get replaced by two AI casters who even quote us :/ I get they are apart of the game but yikes. Thanks @reachthefinals."

Bluepanda, reposting the message, wrote: "For nearly 7 years I've been repeatedly told that my work is valued and appreciated only to then have the same people saying those things turn around and either completely ghost me or tell me they're going in a different direction with talent and that my services aren't needed GG."

Other casters also voiced support. League of Legends caster Sam "Initialise" Hapgood called the move "dystopian," while Jen "LemonKiwi" Pichette described it as "appalling" and said "REAL casters deserve better."

In a post on X, Embark community and competitive operations lead Oscar Lundberg apologized, calling the decision a "mistake." He said the studio intended for Scotty and June to bring more casual interest to The Finals esports ahead of TGM, but that the work of the human talent deserved to be included and highlighted.

"The video is down and won’t return in this form. The AMER and EMEA recaps planned in the same format won’t go out as planned either, and we’re rethinking all three," Lundberg wrote. Embark also told IGN that replacing the casters’ voices with AI "wasn't the right call" and thanked people for their "candid feedback."

Bluepanda told IGN the apology came only after widespread backlash, adding: "It says to me that they're not really sorry at all. I'm done with the game and esports as a whole at this stage, the effort we put in and the amount of bullshit we have to deal with, especially in OCE, just isn't worth it anymore."

ProtoANZ called the situation "a shit show" and urged the creation of an esports talent union. "We'll turn around and say, 'We're not doing this until people send us contracts that essentially ban the use of our voices in generative AI'."