Body weight is shaped by more than personal choice: appetite, genetics, sleep, medicines and food policy can all play a role, according to obesity expert Thomas Barber, Associate Professor and Honorary Consultant Endocrinologist at the University of Warwick.

In his book, Obesity: Life Beyond the GLP-1 Injection, Barber examines factors that shape body weight and their implications for treatment and prevention. The World Health Organization describes obesity as a chronic disease shaped by the interaction between biology and the conditions people live in.

Weight loss can increase hunger. In one study, adults who lost weight on a very low-calorie diet reported feeling hungrier a year after the diet ended than before it began. Their levels of leptin, a hormone that helps tell the brain how much energy the body has stored, remained lower. A review found that energy use can sometimes fall more than expected for a person’s new weight, although this extra drop tended to be smaller in better-designed studies and could fade once weight stabilised.

Genes also influence appetite and body weight. Rarely, a change in a single gene can cause severe obesity in early childhood; more commonly, many genetic differences each contribute a little. In a Norwegian study, average BMI rose over several decades across groups defined by inherited tendency to have a higher BMI, with a bigger rise among those with the strongest tendency. The pattern points to changes in living conditions, with those changes affecting people differently.

Sleep may affect how much people eat. A review of experiments found that people tended to eat more when their sleep was cut short, while evidence that sleep restriction changed calories burned was much weaker. In a two-week trial of 80 adults with overweight who usually slept less than six and a half hours a night, those given tailored sleep advice slept about an hour longer and took in about 270 fewer calories a day on average than those who kept their usual routine. Whether that difference lasts is unclear, and regular sleep hours can be difficult for people who work nights or care for someone.

Semaglutide, which mimics GLP-1 and can help people feel fuller and less hungry, lowered the rate of serious cardiovascular events in a trial of adults with existing heart or circulation problems and overweight or obesity, none of whom had diabetes. Over an average of just over three years, 65 in every 1,000 people taking semaglutide died from cardiovascular causes or had a non-fatal heart attack or stroke, compared with 80 in every 1,000 taking a placebo. About 17 in every 100 people taking semaglutide stopped because of side effects, compared with eight in every 100 taking the placebo.

A separate study followed people for a year after their semaglutide and lifestyle support ended. On average, they regained about two-thirds of the weight they had lost. Barber says people who stop taking the medicine may still need support to manage their weight.

Food choices are also influenced by what is available. In a hospital study, 20 adults spent two weeks on a diet high in ultra-processed foods and two weeks on a diet based on unprocessed foods, with freedom to choose how much to eat. They ate about 500 more calories a day on the ultra-processed diet and ate those meals faster. Eating speed is one possible explanation for the difference.

Food policy can change what is on offer. The UK’s soft drinks levy gave manufacturers a reason to reduce sugar in their recipes to reduce or avoid the charge. An analysis of English school measurements found about 16 fewer cases of obesity per 1,000 girls aged 10 and 11 after the levy came into effect than researchers would have expected if earlier trends had continued. Researchers found no overall reduction among boys of the same age or among children aged four and five, and other changes around the same time could have contributed.

Barber says people living with obesity need access to effective treatment and long-term support. Governments can also help prevent obesity by changing how foods are made and marketed and making nutritious food more affordable where people already shop.