Originally published by buzzfeed.com.
by Megan LiscombSenior EditorAs a Senior Editor at BuzzFeed, I cover lifestyle topics including books, work and money, health, and home.
At this point, we all know that what we see on reality TV isn't exactly a great reflection of actual reality (at least, I hope we all know that). Well, recently, people on Reddit spilled the reality TV secrets they know from working behind the scenes, appearing on a show, or being close to someone who has, and I couldn't stop combing through the thread for all the best stories. Here's what people shared:
Disclaimer: We can't 100% confirm these stories, but these people are allegedly speaking from their own experiences on reality shows, know someone who's been on reality shows, or simply have insider knowledge.
Comments have been edited for length and clarity.
1. "I worked on America's Got Talent for one season, and I had never watched the show before working on it. I spent four days working, interviewing talented people with a camera crew and a producer. I will never forget that we interviewed an older woman who was a drummer. She was vibrant and friendly, and we had a great talk, and then I watched when the episode aired."
NBC / Getty Images"They recut the interview to make her seem flighty and mentally...off. Then she goes out on stage in front of the country for Sharon Osbourne to mock her.
It was bad, it was heartbreaking, that this woman's crime was being older than 40 and good at drums, and the people making that show took the liberty to destroy her on a national platform.
They asked me to work on the next season, and I turned them down without a conversation."
—RealLiveLawyer
2. "My friend worked on a Storage Wars-type show. They would rent props and interesting items to put in the storage unit to make things more exciting."
—anoba69
3. "My sister was on House Hunters, and they cut everything to make her look like a massive bitch. Like, she can be a bit domineering at times, but they really made it look like she was insufferable. I guess they try to manufacture drama in the final edit, even when it is bullshit."
"They literally have a team that moves all your stuff out to make it look like a property that's staged for sale, then move everything back in to show the post-'purchase' parts. She said the moving crew was crazy efficient and took a ton of pictures, so when they brought everything back in, they placed it all basically inch-perfect."
—ender4171
4. "My best friend was featured on My Cat From Hell with Jackson Galaxy 15 or so years ago. They had two cats who hated each other's guts. The actual filming was really fun: They did interviews and gave the cats GoPros to wear for a week. Jackson and the crew were great. But I have 20+ years of experience in animal rescue and animal behavior modification. Those two cats were a lost cause. There was no way to ever make them reconcile."
David Becker / Getty Images"The final episode was edited in such a way that it looks like the cats became best friends at the end.
In reality, the cats hated each other just like before, and eventually one got rehomed. They both have since passed away."
—26pointMax
5. "I worked on Wife Swap, two seasons of it. I can tell you without hesitation that every single moment you saw of that show was the result of a director taking everyone aside and explaining what they were each to do during the next scene. They were allowed to improvise but things like, 'Okay we want you to argue over the color of the sofa, just get wild with it,' and they'd pretend to be angry with each other because the sofa was beige. The whole show was that level of contrived fake bullshit from start to end."
—ArcadianDelSol
6. "My brother was on one of those paranormal shows where they interviewed him about his experience and then filmed him for reenactments. He would answer the questions truthfully, but they would have him answer again with more embellishments. The funniest part was when they asked him why he moved out of the house."
"His answer was that he got a new job and moved in with his girlfriend. They had him change his answer to say the experience just got too terrifying, and he had to leave immediately. They even filmed a 'reenactment' with him hurriedly stuffing clothes into a suitcase."
—4StarCustoms
7. "I worked on one season of Extreme Makeover: Home Edition. Everyone knew at least eight months in advance that they were chosen. They filmed fake shots of the crew rolling up in trucks and the family being all 'Whaaaaat is going on right now? What is all this?' They knew because you have to get all the permits and approvals in place MONTHS before a single hammer is put into a single hand."
Raymond Liu / Getty Images"The reveals at the end were also faked. They would do multiple takes of it. While the family legit saw the home for the first time in some of those shots, they would do them a few times so they had enough B-roll to cut in and out of it."
—ArcadianDelSol
8. "A very good friend of mine, whom I dated and lived with for five years, worked sound on a lot of reality shows in the early aughts, so he taught me the power of editing (never trust the words when you can only see the back of their head kinda thing). What stuck out to me was when he talked about the producer manipulation and said he couldn't watch the (scripted) show Unreal. He joked that it uncovered a lot of buried trauma for his complicity in all of it and then proceeded to get therapy about it."
—oogmar
"I work in reality TV post; we have a term for it: Frankenbiting. I've told anyone who will listen: Do not audition; do not try to get on reality TV. We can make you say whatever we want."
—yohomatey
9. "I worked on some HGTV shows. The properties they tour aren’t real, and most owners already live in the home they chose to begin with."
—TheLastLook
"I know someone who was on one of those shows, and that's exactly what happened. They contacted him right after he bought a house, then led him through several other houses, and he finally 'chose' the house he had already bought."
—TallEnoughJones
10. "I was a guest diner on a Gordon Ramsay show. They serve bad/undercooked food on purpose to get a reaction they can film. I had a camera shoved in my face and was instructed to complain about how awful my dish was. I also heard them tell a couple seated next to me to complain about the wait times so they could film it."
FOX / Getty Images—Much_Discipline_7303
"On the other side, one of his shows featured a local restaurant near me. We had visited the restaurant a couple of months before, and it was even more horrible than what was shown on TV. Everything tasted rancid, and it seemed like the grill had never been cleaned. I felt they got a soft edit."
—Melleous
11. "I was on The Voice UK a few years back. The order things were shot in was not necessarily the order they were shown in. I was eliminated in the Battle Round (two singers on the same team go head to head, and their coach chooses who stays and who goes). At that point, one of the three other coaches can choose to take the contestant being eliminated, but they can only do that once. Tom Jones had expressed interest in having me on his team at my chair turn, but then at the battle round didn't pick me. Lots of people on Twitter asked why he hadn't picked me."
"The real reason was that although my battle episode aired first out of that entire season, it was filmed near the middle, and he'd already used his steal on someone else earlier, but their episode was then broadcast a week or two later."
—melaszepheos
12. "A friend of mine was on the MTV reality show Parental Control. The premise of the show was that the kid had a terrible boyfriend or girlfriend that their parents hated. The parents would pick three potential suitors to replace the partner. The kid would go on dates and decide who they wanted to end up with. Anyway, my friend was cast to play the terrible boyfriend."
"He met his 'girlfriend' the day of the shoot and said production told him how to act, what to wear, and manufactured a whole relationship. The dates were real, albeit highly produced. But the relationships on the show were fake. Both the romantic ones and parental ones."
—stonewalled87
13. "Years ago, I worked as a PA for American Idol. During the very first auditions (known as 'the cull'), I guess the producers identify people that they think are going to wow the celebrity judges via talent or story, and they send out crews to do home stories. These are the bits that show the contestant’s home life that usually air right before their first appearance in front of the celebrity judges. I was sent with a producer/camera person to a small town to interview a person and their family for a few hours."
Kevin Winter / Getty Images"The process was kind of funny, as since it was just the two of us, they treated me like I was someone important that they needed to impress. They gave me a jar of homemade jam.
Anyway, the sad part was that the contestant didn’t make it through the celebrity judge round, and I don’t think the footage was ever used."
—kit_kat_barcalounger
14. "A friend of mine was on one of the competition-type reality shows where they have everyone live together in one space and get voted off as the season goes on. He was doing well, getting along with people and making the cut for the first few challenges. Then he got appendicitis and had to drop out because he was in the hospital recovering."
"When the show aired, he saw that they had developed a storyline where he was the 'bad one' that was always causing problems with the other contestants. The editors picked out enough footage and dialogue to make it look like that was the reason he left the house. If you didn't know what really happened, you would have no idea it was any different than what was on the screen."
—BlingBlingBlingo
15. "I worked as a PA on Pawn Stars. They have a replica of the actual pawn shop used just for filming the episodes, and they hire extras to just walk around the shop while filming."
—No-Nefariousness150
16. "I'm a veteran, successful 'unscripted' aka reality TV producer that has worked on some of the biggest shows you've heard of. You know how some cast members just hit it out of the park in their confessionals, like always delivering great one-liners, sound bites, and hilarious reads on their fellow cast (Bethenny Frankel on RHONY is a great example)? That's all because she (and all talent) have specific directors they are assigned to work with throughout all of filming, and that producer, along with a story producing team in post that's watching all the footage and building an episode with what we get, work together."
Bravo / Via youtube.com"We start the season by filming regular interviews, just asking cast about all the things happening and hoping the talent delivers those golden bites for us naturally...but once the season is really rolling in field a post, a lot of times you just really need one super tight, all-encompassing line from one person to puzzle piece in and bring the whole scene together.
That means, often, a story producer does write up (never call it scripting), like, 5+ options for the cast members to try and say for that spot. You'd be shocked at how many of the most iconic interview moments from your fave cast members were really just written by a super low-paid post-producer desperate under a deadline for one clean line under 10 seconds to slice in. Like, really, really surprised. The cast members with the best interviews really just have the BEST producers on their team."
—jinxybardot
17. "I worked in casting on a dating show: They're all actors. Even when they list in the intro that they are a real estate agent or dental assistant or whatever, they're actors that have those things as side jobs. They're not looking to date someone; they're looking to be seen on TV. A lot of them are in relationships already that they hide (or get asked to hide) for the casting."
—WhoIsYerWan
18. "I own a music school. About 15 years ago, one of our voice students auditioned for America's Got Talent. She was basically told, 'You're good, but we've filled all the good slots for this season, and we're looking for clowns.' I guess if they can't find those roles, they manufacture them."
—TomSerb
19. "I cringe to admit this, but our business (a pottery studio in NYC) was part of a task on The Apprentice where a team took the keys from us for a day and competed against a team that had selected another business (car wash, florist). Prior to filming, they had a whole test cast come in and run different scenarios to see how much drama they could manufacture. Could something blow up in a kiln? Could a customer break a million things? Everything was skewed toward invented conflict/drama, not business. Ultimately, we were not included in the episode, and we were grateful."
Bill Tompkins / Getty Images—Lennymud
20. "My friend and I were on the Judge Mathis show about a small claims lawsuit we were having. They flew us from LA to Chicago. Although we had mostly come to an agreement between us beforehand, they encouraged us to be extremely confrontational, angry, and upset. Plus, they gave us unlimited Coca-Cola and candy before the show for hours. We were both so dizzy and jacked up for the taping that we made crazy, inflammatory, unkind accusations that we later both regretted."
—manicgiant914
21. "I was on a makeover reality show in the mid-2000s. I worked in kids' entertainment at the time, so one day we shot at a Disney Store. They edited it to look like I had gone rogue and run off to the Disney Store without permission, as an act of rebellion or whatever."
"After it aired, I was surprised by how many people were like, 'I can't believe you did that; that was messed up,' etc. Like, you think I was able to just spontaneously waltz into a Disney Store with a camera crew? They had been setting that shoot up for weeks. All locations require permits, scheduling, and often a fee."
—Moobook
22. "About 15 years ago, I was cooking at a trendy restaurant in Palm Beach. The Kardashian show was coming in for dinner. The crew came about 1 1/2 hours early to set up. The whole cast, minus Kim, showed up and took the big shared table, ordered a pile of food, ate and talked, and then Kim arrived, and they did it all over again, including arriving, valeting, and coming in."
Hulu / Courtesy Everett Collection—cookinggun
23. "In the '90s, I used to work for a place that produced a ton of magazines; some of them were of an adult variety. Talk shows used to call us to fill specific roles. One situation I remember was for Sally Jessy Raphael."
"They were looking for a younger man, much older woman situation. So we sent over a 60-year-old model with our gay art director, in his early 30s, to be her younger husband. When they got there, the producers threw in another young guy who she was supposed to be having an affair with. This is only one of the fake situations we were asked to help with."
—WingardiemLeviosa
24. "When I first moved to LA, all starry-eyed, I got invited to a taping of America's Got Talent. I'm not even a fan of the show, but I wanted to see what a taping in LA was like, so I excitedly went on the date I was given around noon. I showed up to the studio with a bunch of other tourist suckers like me and some people who were paid minimum wage to fill seats in the studio. They took our phones and sat us down in the auditorium. What I quickly learned was that there were noon tapings and evening tapings."
"For our noon taping, there was literally a SINGLE act — a guy who knocked down dominoes on stage. It was, like, one minute total.
Then they proceeded to record us clapping and applauding to imaginary acts that didn't exist; FOR TWO HOURS. The irony being the audience-recorded audio had to be real despite them being okay faking the show as if we were watching anything.
The hosts came in for literally two minutes of recording, then left. It was such a bizarre and puzzling waste of my time. I'd have left earlier, except they locked the doors and had our phones until the end."
—owen__wilsons__nose
25. "Someone I know was featured on This Old House. They said they were shocked at how authentic it turned out to be. The only difference was that there were workers completing the project who were not shown on camera."
PBS / courtesy Everett Collection—Nvnv_man
26. "One of my neighbors worked on the transformation crew for one of the episodes of Kitchen Nightmares. The 'overnight transformation' also is not actually overnight. It actually takes a week or more. They basically pay everyone involved with the restaurant to fuck off for a while. For this specific episode, they had a subset of the crew take the owner and his family down to Cincinnati for a few days while the construction crew did its thing. My neighbor was on the construction crew that was brought in to renovate the place."
"When they film the 'after' section, they also bring in the families of the construction crew that helped transform the restaurant and specifically prompt them to say positive things about the food/service before they even get to sit down. My neighbor and his family were featured in that part of the episode. His coworkers and their families are also in the episode as well.
To be fair to the show, the restaurant DID actually just fucking suck beforehand. They also sucked afterward, and they closed two or three months after they filmed the show because the owner couldn't stop being an asshole. By the time the episode aired, they were already closed."
—bbbbbthatsfivebees
27. And finally, "I’ve been on multiple reality competition shows. On one show, the terms and conditions stated that the host (a celebrity) would determine if an answer was correct or incorrect. I didn’t understand how there could possibly be discretion until I saw it play out. One contestant that had a strong narrative (needed the win/money for medical expenses for their kid, was a teacher with an out-of-work husband) was asked, 'What are the two non-contiguous states in the US?' The contestant replied, 'Guam and Puerto Rico,' which was met with gasps from the audience."
"The host said, ‘Come on, contestant X, think about it,’ after which the contestant said Alaska and Hawaii…and, of course, when the show aired, it was cut to just show the correct answer, as if that’s how it played out live during the taping.
The next contestant, who did not have as strong of a narrative, was asked, 'What day is Earth Day each year?' to which the person answered, like, one day off, and the host immediately hit the wrong answer button and eliminated them.
So yeah, tee-ball questions vs. very hard question-type manipulation plus built-in discretion packaged with the magic of editing can help certain contestants advance vs. others, which, as a viewer, you likely just assume is ‘luck of the draw’ or ‘fairness’…but behind the scenes, it can be anything but."
—daddymcdadjokes
