The 2027 Grammy Best New Artist nominees include Angine de Poitrine, Don Toliver, Ella Langley, Geese, Remi Wolf, Sienna Spiro, Slayyyter and The Womack Sisters. The nomination slate has renewed questions about how the Recording Academy defines a “new” artist, particularly given the established careers of some nominees.

The Recording Academy’s rules say the award “recognizes the excellence of an artist whose eligibility-period release(s) have had significant cultural and community impact upon the industry and the musical landscape.” There is no specified maximum number of previous releases, but screening committees may disqualify artists they determine had already reached that level of impact before the eligibility year.

For the 2027 slate, artists may be submitted four times instead of three. The allowance covers submissions, not nominations: an artist can be submitted and miss the final list before returning in a later year. An extensive discography alone is not disqualifying; committees weigh the impact of earlier work. Eligibility and nomination are separate decisions. According to Billboard, 331 acts competed for eight Best New Artist slots.

Angine de Poitrine released its second album, Vol. II, on April 3rd, 2026, within the eligibility window of August 31st, 2025, to August 28th, 2026. The release came two months after the band’s viral KEXP set in February 2026. The article describes the nomination as surprising but says the band’s activity during the eligibility period fits the award’s impact criteria.

Don Toliver’s nomination is more contentious, the article argues. He has released five major-label albums in six years, along with two mixtapes and two collaborative JackBoys records with Travis Scott, Sheck Wes and other Cactus Jack acts. He was also technically nominated for a Grammy for his work on Kanye West’s Donda in 2022. His breakout single “No Idea” came out seven years ago and reached #43 on the Billboard Hot 100.

The article says Toliver’s album Octane and singles “ATM,” “Body” and “E85” made this his biggest year yet, broadening his reach among multi-genre listeners. It also notes that “No Idea” and “After Party” have both been certified Triple Platinum by the RIAA, and argues that those earlier successes raise questions about whether he should be considered new.