Hundreds protested outside a Rutgers University building in New Brunswick, New Jersey, on Monday night as former border patrol commander Greg Bovino spoke to an audience of about 25 people. The university’s Republicans club had invited him to campus.

Bovino was a prominent figure in the Trump administration’s immigration crackdown, overseeing Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) operations in Chicago, Minneapolis and other US cities. After agents killed Minneapolis residents Alex Pretti and Renee Good in January, scrutiny of the enforcement operation intensified. Bovino, who called Pretti a “suspect” rather than a victim, was removed from the field by the end of the month and retired in March, reportedly while under internal investigation.

About a dozen protesters interrupted Bovino’s talk. One shouted, “What’s so crazy is that you all allowed a Nazi to be here,” while another yelled, “Your fascist death cult is failing!” Police officers stood near the stage. Bovino left briefly as police told protesters to stop disrupting the event or disperse; most complied, and he returned to speak.

Immigration advocate Gabriela Soto helped lead the protest. Her husband, Martín, had helped organize hunger strikes over conditions and deaths at New Jersey’s Delaney Hall immigration detention facility earlier this year. After he was transferred to another facility in May, protests continued for weeks. Gabriela was pregnant when Martín was taken into ICE custody and miscarried while he was held in solitary confinement.

At the event, Soto stood on a chair and shouted, “You’re taking children! It’s not OK!” Other protesters and students also voiced concerns about the safety of immigrants, students with immigrant family members and international students who feared being targeted by ICE.

During the talk, Bovino asked the audience, “Show of hands, can we remove 100 million illegal aliens by 2028? Do you think we can?” Two or three people raised their hands. “Well, I’m telling you what, my hand’s raised! American exceptionalism! We can do it before then!” he said.

In the question-and-answer session, retired teacher Alan Cummings challenged Bovino’s goal of 100m deportations, noting that the estimated number of undocumented immigrants in the US is a fraction of that figure. Bovino responded that Cummings was not proud to be American. Bovino also referred repeatedly to a Michigan city that banned LGBTQ+ pride flags in 2023, made a seemingly homophobic pun on Pete Buttigieg’s last name and ridiculed New Jersey governor Mikie Sherrill. Earlier on Monday, Sherrill had condemned the event but did not call for its cancellation.

The event had drawn criticism since Rutgers’s College Republicans announced it the previous month. The ICE Out of New Jersey coalition and student organizers urged the university to cancel it; a student petition received more than 2,000 signatures. Rutgers assistant vice-president of news and media relations Dory Devlin said the university supported freedom of expression, but that “providing space for a student-organized event does not constitute university endorsement of the speaker or the views expressed”.

“We are all about free speech,” said Brea Yumiguano, a Rutgers senior and student organizer with Climate Revolution Action Network. “The issue comes when it’s Greg Bovino, someone who has been violent in the past, who has eroded our constitutional rights, who’s pepper-sprayed protesters in Minneapolis – that’s not what we want in New Brunswick.”

A Rutgers sophomore identified as Ninnie cried as she told the crowd she did not feel safe bringing her family to campus, citing reports of ICE agents targeting local public transportation. “There are plenty of us students here who are people of color who are afraid to have our family members come visit us at Rutgers,” she said.

Most protesters left after more than an hour of chanting to drums and bagpipes. Those who remained at Bovino’s talk later left through a police security perimeter. A “prosecute Bovino” sign was left by an exit. Jorge Torres of the National Day Laborer Organizing Network, an ICE Out coalition member who interrupted the speech, said: “This is an example of what New Jersey is about: New Jersey is an immigrants’ rights state. We welcome immigrants,” and, “We don’t want no neo-Nazis in our state.”