International Men’s Day, observed on Nov. 19, offers an opportunity to ask which men are struggling and why, rather than debate whether men as a whole are “falling behind,” the authors write.
Men, on average, continue to have advantages in the labour market, but social class, race and migrant background can shape men’s education and employment prospects. The authors say that treating men as a single group can obscure the barriers facing those from disadvantaged backgrounds.
In a review of research from several western countries, mainly the United States, United Kingdom and parts of the European Union, the authors searched Google Scholar for intersectional studies of gender. They found 1,330 studies with “women” in the title, compared with 234 mentioning “men.” In research on career advancement, studies of women’s promotion that also considered race or ethnicity outnumbered comparable studies of men by about 80 to one.
The authors note that equity research has focused strongly on women because women have historically faced, and continue to face, substantial barriers in education and employment. But they argue that comparatively little is known about men who do not share advantages typically associated with being male.
Disadvantages can begin at school. Boys from low-income families and racialized or stigmatized migrant backgrounds tend to fall behind, and teacher expectations may contribute to whether students finish school. According to social scientist Richard Reeves, young men in the United States are almost 50 per cent more likely than young women to drop out of high school.
In Canada, the 2021 census shows that about one-quarter of Canadian-born men aged 25 to 34 held a bachelor’s degree or higher, compared with almost 40 per cent of Canadian-born women in the same age group. The authors say educational disadvantages increasingly shape later labour-market prospects.
The authors describe a shift away from relatively well-paid work available to less-educated men. In 1970, high school dropouts held 43 per cent of American manufacturing jobs. By 2016, fewer than 10 per cent of those jobs were held by workers who had not finished high school. Many such jobs have disappeared, while those remaining increasingly require formal qualifications.
Employers also place greater value on cognitive, interpersonal and communication skills. Research on class and gender stereotypes shows cognitive and interpersonal skills are more strongly associated with upper-class men, while working-class men are more likely to be associated with physical strength and toughness, the authors write.
Employment is growing in health care, education, administration and literacy occupations. The authors say an aging population is increasing demand for care workers, while advances in artificial intelligence are likely to make interpersonal and emotional skills more important because machines have difficulty replicating them.
Men remain substantially under-represented in much of this work. In Canada, about 91 per cent of regulated nurses are women, and only about 25 per cent of elementary and high school teachers are men. The authors say many working-class men have not been prepared for these occupations or encouraged to see them as realistic career choices.
The authors argue that improving opportunities for disadvantaged men need not come at the expense of women’s gains. They cite French economists who have argued that revaluing female-dominated occupations could advance pay equity for women while drawing more men into the work. Raising wages in undervalued care work would help women already doing it while opening a door for men.
They also cite a French study that found male midwives helped the profession’s push for better recognition. Bringing more men into areas such as health care could also address staff shortages in sectors that remain overwhelmingly made up of women.
The authors recommend that schools pay closer attention to expectations for boys at risk of disengaging, and that governments and employers strengthen vocational pathways into occupations with labour shortages. They also say children need to see more men working as teachers, nurses and care workers so boys can imagine those careers for themselves.
The authors say stable work, economic security and a sense of purpose matter to individual and social well-being. International Men’s Day, they argue, should prompt a nuanced conversation: men remain advantaged in many areas, but not all men share those advantages.
Eddy Ng receives funding from the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada. Alain Klarsfeld and Brandon Legacy do not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and have disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.
Source: The Conversation — Eddy Ng, Smith Professor of Equity and Inclusion in Business, Queen's University, Ontario, Alain Klarsfeld, Professeur de gestion des ressources humaines, TBS Education, Brandon Legacy, PhD Candidate, Smith School of Business, Queen's University, Ontario.
