The launch of a new pro-Brexit campaign surprised Westminster, but its arguments echoed familiar campaign tactics. Stay Out, run by former deputy chief Brexit negotiator Oliver Lewis, released a video on X over the weekend featuring riots in France, champagne flowing in Brussels and European politicians saying how desperate they were for Britain’s cash.

The campaign has claimed that returning to the EU would cost £750m a week. For now, pro-rejoin freelancers are rebutting its claims on social media, without a central organisation. One MP said a new campaign could not begin until the government’s direction was clear.

“There are organisations that exist already, like Best for Britain, but I think making the case to the public would need a fresh movement,” the MP said. They added that they wanted to avoid marches like those held by the People’s Vote movement with the blue berets.

Inside No 10, there is confidence that Andy Burnham can make the case for closer ties with Europe without an external pressure group. Stay Out will be dubbed “the status quo campaign”. Labour polling seen by strategists shows 71% of voters support a closer relationship with Europe if it helps bring down prices and grow the economy.

Strategists say the prime minister can lead any campaigning, arguing that Brexit has done more harm than good by damaging the economy, making it harder for British people to travel and businesses to trade, and fuelling the small boats crisis.

Some fear this approach could repeat David Cameron’s failed effort to make the case for remaining in the EU in 2016. Labour strategists argue the political moment is different. “Cameron could not make this kind of emotional connection with people, it was business leaders, facts and figures, and he was arguing for the status quo,” one said. “We are the change campaign now.”

Some cabinet members remain uncertain about Burnham’s direction on Europe. Many voiced caution at last week’s cabinet meeting, although most are prepared to trust him to set out a viable plan for the next steps post summit.

There is also concern among some Labour allies about leaving the argument solely to Burnham. One asked: “Can they do this from the bowels of Downing Street?” The source added that rebuttal and people prepared to campaign were needed, saying the infrastructure was not yet in place.

A veteran of the remain campaign said there was concern about being “left out on a limb” if a rejoin campaign was revived. “I think whether they like it or not there will be an apolitical campaign trying to push the maximalist position on Europe. They have people willing to help but it’s not organised in any way.”

Some former remain and People’s Vote campaigners remain scarred by the experience, particularly the final months, which descended into bitter infighting. Some high-profile Vote Leave veterans also want to steer clear of Stay Out.

There are often willing funders for pro-European campaigning, as there were for pro-Brexit campaigns. “It will happen because there will be money for it,” one campaign veteran said. “But you could not pay me any money to go back to that issue.”