A police raid at a Mount Waverley home has failed to recover three Melbourne Cup trophies won by champion mare Makybe Diva, each valued at $1m by Victoria police. The trophies were stolen from Flemington racecourse in a smash-and-grab on Monday morning.

Thieves smashed a glass display case at the racecourse about 6.30am. Police raided the home in Melbourne’s east on Monday evening and arrested a 36-year-old Malvern East man. He was interviewed and released, pending summons.

The cups were won by Makybe Diva in 2003, 2004 and 2005 and had been on public display at Flemington since September. The champion horse died in February at the age of 27 after a short and sudden battle with a gastrointestinal condition.

Former owner Tony Santic told 3AW that Makybe Diva was “the people’s horse”. “Hopefully we can get them back in one piece,” Santic said. “It’s more than devastating. I just can’t believe it. I just want to try to get them back and hopefully we get them back in one piece.”

The Victorian Racing Club said it was devastated by the theft and was in direct contact with Santic. It said Victoria police was investigating the incident.