International Atomic Energy Agency chief Rafael Grossi has placed second in the latest United Nations Security Council straw poll for secretary-general, as questions grow over whether his ties to US President Donald Trump and Argentinian President Javier Milei will hinder his candidacy.

Grossi received nine “encourage” votes and four “discourage” votes. Costa Rica’s Rebeca Grynspan led the poll, with eight candidates still in the race to replace Antonio Guterres, who must leave office on December 31.

Grossi, 65, has drawn both admiration and criticism for his tenure at the IAEA. Supporters point to his hands-on diplomacy in conflict zones, while critics, particularly in Iran, have accused him of partisanship.

Jan Wouters, a professor of international law and international organisations at KU Leuven in Belgium, said Grossi has “transformed the technical watchdog into a highly visible, proactive diplomatic actor”. Wouters said he raised the agency’s profile through “constant shuttle diplomacy and direct engagement with world leaders”.

Grossi has led inspection teams to Ukraine’s Zaporizhzhia and Chernobyl nuclear power plants since Russia’s full-scale invasion in 2022. In Ukraine, Wouters said, Grossi focused on technical safety rather than territorial sovereignty and “successfully brokered eight localised ceasefires between Russia and Ukraine to allow critical plant repairs”.

Ezequiel Jimenez Martinez, an adjunct professor at Pompeu Fabra Law Faculty in Barcelona, said Grossi’s active role has “angered” Russia, which has a veto on the Security Council and considers him to have exceeded his remit as IAEA chief.

A secretary-general candidate needs at least nine votes from the 15-member Security Council and must avoid a veto from any of its five permanent members: the US, the UK, France, Russia and China. The 193-member General Assembly then has to approve the choice.

Neither China nor Russia has publicly announced a preference. The South China Morning Post reported that Beijing had ruled out Grossi as too close to Washington and would instead back Grynspan, while analysts say the two countries are unlikely to support a candidate closely aligned with the US.

Iran has also opposed Grossi’s candidacy, although it is not on the Security Council. Foreign Ministry spokesman Esmaeil Baghaei this month accused the IAEA of being overly influenced by the US and European countries in its “one-sided and biased reporting about Iran’s peaceful nuclear programme”.

The IAEA estimated that Iran held 440.9kg (972lb) of uranium enriched to up to 60 percent before the June 2025 Israeli-US attacks on its nuclear facilities. Uranium must be enriched to 90 percent to become weapons-grade, but enrichment can proceed quickly from 60 percent. The agency said the amount could produce 10 nuclear weapons if enriched further.

Jimenez Martinez said Grossi could withstand criticism over Iran because “the majority of governors of the agency agree with his approach on Iran”. In the UN race, he said, the issue would cause “a bit of fireworks, but I don’t think it will change many votes”.

Observers say Grossi’s technical credentials may not be enough to advance his campaign. Candidates are also expected to be seen as defenders of the UN Charter and the organisation’s international law and human rights instruments. Milei’s support is viewed as Grossi’s main liability.

Milei has described international institutions as threats to national sovereignty and individual liberty, calling the UN “useless” and its diplomats “fatally arrogant parasites”. Since taking office in 2023, he has revived Argentina’s dispute with the UK over the Falkland Islands, which Argentina calls the Malvinas, and told UN delegates that self-determination should not apply to the islands’ population.

The Trump administration has criticised the UN, withdrawn the US from key agencies, cut its funding and bypassed the organisation in launching the war on Iran in February. Jimenez Martinez said Grossi is seen as close to both Trump and Milei and as likely to advance an agenda aligned with their foreign policies.

“This will mean in practice a shrinking of the UN structure,” Jimenez Martinez said, including merging agencies and refocusing the organisation on security and peace rather than development. Grossi has urged world leaders to have the “courage to reform” the institution. Jimenez Martinez said Grossi’s calls to cut red tape, without detailing safeguards, were unlikely to win General Assembly approval.

Alvina Hoffmann, a senior lecturer in diplomatic studies at SOAS University of London, said Grossi is widely viewed as focused on improving the system and reducing overlapping mandates “rather than addressing the structural drivers of inequality”. She said his preference for personal leadership, confidential negotiations and preventive diplomacy “rather than issuing public declarations or condemnations” might limit his ability to speak out against violations of international law.

Under the tradition of geographical rotation, the secretary-general post should next go to a Latin American. Five women are candidates, while public and civil society pressure to appoint the first woman to the role is at an all-time high. Grynspan is a Latin American woman candidate.

Ben Donaldson, an adviser to the 1 for 8 Billion campaign advocating for the first female secretary-general, said appointment on merit “is not inconsistent with gender considerations”. He said General Assembly resolutions and international standards call for due regard to gender balance in senior UN leadership, and that member states should consider how candidates’ experience and personal characteristics reflect the diversity of the international community.

“The United Nations has existed for 80 years without ever appointing a woman as secretary-general,” Donaldson said. “This persistent imbalance stands in contrast to the organisation’s own commitments to equality, parity and nondiscrimination.”