A religious ruling by Rabbi Gedalia Axelrod invoking the Jewish legal principle din rodef has prompted condemnation and calls for a criminal investigation in Israel, where political tensions during government-formation negotiations have revived memories of the climate before Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin’s 1995 assassination.

In a letter published last week, Axelrod, a former head of Haifa’s rabbinical court, issued a ruling that could be used to justify killing politicians accused of facilitating a government backed by Arab-led parties. Yigal Amir invoked the same principle to justify killing Rabin, who had signed the Oslo Accords with the Palestinians.

“The Torah obliges me,” Axelrod later told the Israeli news website Walla. “I knew it was not easy, but if the Torah obliges, then we go. We are Jews, we make sacrifices.” The Chabad Hasidic movement, to which Axelrod belongs, has distanced itself from his remarks.

Twenty former senior Israeli security, military and public figures, including former heads of intelligence agencies, have called on authorities to investigate Axelrod. Left-wing lawmakers Ofer Cassif and Michal Rozin have also demanded an investigation, warning of the growing risk of political violence.

The controversy follows Israel’s parliamentary election in late October, in which parties representing Palestinian citizens of Israel won 19 of the parliament’s 120 seats. Parties opposed to caretaker Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu hold a parliamentary majority, but several opposition members have refused to cooperate with the Arab parties.

The phrase din rodef, or the “law of the pursuer”, evokes the tensions and incitement before Rabin was killed on November 4, 1995. Rabin’s widow, Leah, accused Netanyahu, then opposition leader, of helping foster hostility. She pointed to his presence at a rally a month before the assassination, where protesters displayed an effigy of Rabin dressed in a Nazi uniform.

Amir argued that Rabin’s pursuit of the Oslo Accords endangered Jewish lives. Axelrod’s ruling similarly claims that an alliance with an Arab-led party would put Jewish lives at risk.

Israeli sociologist Yehouda Shenhav-Shahrabani described the merging of politics and religion as “political theology”. “By political theology, I mean the way ideas about God, sacred authority and the chosen people shape political life,” he said, describing rules about who is entitled to rule, who may belong and whose life must be protected. “Sometimes these ideas are explicit, as in a rabbi invoking divine law against an elected politician. But they can also survive in apparently secular ideas about the nation, sovereignty and historical destiny.”

“Someone who accepts Arab participation in government can then be portrayed as betraying a sacred community, and violence against them can become, in the eyes of a believer, a religious duty,” Shenhav-Shahrabani said of the rationale behind Axelrod’s ruling.

“The threat of political violence is really high,” Cassif told Al Jazeera. “We all remember what happened in 1995 and the atmosphere that preceded Rabin’s assassination. This time it’s worse. Then it was just a few extremists on the fringe; now it’s the mainstream. They’re being openly encouraged by a prime minister who, I think, is ready to consider or do anything to hold on to power.”

Cassif also cited the role of far-right National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir in the atmosphere before Rabin’s killing. In October 1995, Ben-Gvir was filmed holding the hood ornament torn from Rabin’s car and telling journalists, “We got to his car, and we’ll get to him, too.”

Fears of far-right violence have grown during prolonged coalition negotiations. Netanyahu and his right-wing Likud party have repeatedly sought to vilify Arab-led parties during the campaign ahead of the October 27 election and in subsequent statements. Netanyahu accused the parties of allying with foreign and hostile powers. At the new parliament’s swearing-in on November 10, he called incoming Palestinian politicians “terror supporters, haters of Israel” and denounced opposition politicians considering working with them.

Days earlier, right-wing protesters gathered outside the Herzliya home of Gadi Eisenkot, the opposition leader tasked with forming a government, and called the former general and chief of staff a traitor. One protester accused Eisenkot of murdering his son, Gal, who was killed in Gaza in December 2023. The protester told Eisenkot’s wife, Hannah, that she would be joining her son.

“Obviously, this is a tense time,” said Daniel Bar-Tal, a political psychologist at Tel Aviv University who has studied political violence. “The ultra-rightists will try to stop the process of changing regimes,” he said, drawing parallels with the January 6, 2021, attack on the United States Capitol by supporters of President Donald Trump. “Thus, it is a dangerous situation.”

“What Netanyahu is doing now is what he’s been doing for years: taking the Arabs, [and] the democratic Jews who work with them, and presenting them to the Israeli public as an overwhelming threat,” Cassif said. “Using minorities and their supporters as a scapegoat has always been a cornerstone of nationalist right-wing policy, and so it is in present-day Israel.”