Cricket Australia will not reopen its investigation into the 2018 ball-tampering scandal, but plans to establish an independent forum where players and staff can share their accounts of events, describing it as a “circuit breaker”.
The scandal returned to the spotlight last week after Usman Khawaja’s autobiography alleged that the whole team knew about a plan to rough up the ball with sandpaper. Current captain Pat Cummins strenuously denied the allegation.
Cricket Australia’s original investigation found that only then-captain Steve Smith, vice-captain David Warner and Cameron Bancroft knew about the plan. All three were sent home and banned. Warner, who supports Khawaja’s account, accused the governing body over the weekend of conducting “a shoddy investigation” and said not all players had been interviewed.
Chief executive Todd Greenberg said the past week had been an “incredibly difficult and uncomfortable time for the game and for everyone who was involved”. Speaking in Hobart ahead of Australia’s one-day match against England on Wednesday, he said “the investigation has been completed” and ruled out making it public, citing confidentiality.
“We’ve got almost everyone’s version of events, and they differ markedly,” Greenberg said. He added that the forum was not intended to establish a definitive account: “Looking for the perfect truth doesn’t exist, and we’re not chasing that.”
Interim chairman David Boon said the forum, likely to be led by a former judge, would let players and staff involved in the events in South Africa in 2018 share their experiences. No new sanctions would result. Boon said it was “not about litigating the past” but about giving those involved an opportunity to be heard.
Cricket Australia has not committed to publishing the forum’s contents and hopes to complete the process within a month. Greenberg said it would be “as transparent as we possibly can” while protecting the confidentiality of participants. He denied the forum was intended to appease Warner, saying: “This is not about appeasing any individual. This is about the game; it’s about the sport.”
Greenberg said Cricket Australia also had to take responsibility for the team environment in 2018. He described the culture as “quite toxic” and said: “It was a difficult dressing room. It was a win-at-all-costs mentality, and that doesn’t just start with a group of players. It comes from an entire organisation.”
Warner said he agreed there should be no further sanctions but would have preferred an open inquiry. “It’s not about penalties. It’s about transparency and accountability,” he said, adding that Greenberg had acknowledged Cricket Australia’s role in the culture at the time.
Khawaja welcomed a “safe space to chat” but questioned whether a forum held behind closed doors would provide transparency. He said the board would decide what information was released.
