Shabana Mahmood is to announce a fast-track scheme to train 200 people a year for future police leadership roles, following a report that found leadership in forces in England and Wales was inconsistent and sometimes “frankly inadequate”.
Mahmood will outline the programme to police chiefs and leaders at their annual conference in central London on Wednesday. The scheme will be open to people from any job, including those outside law enforcement, and does not require a degree. Recruits will be put on a five to 10-year path towards superintendent, according to government sources.
“The conclusions of the Police Leadership Commission were candid and eye-opening. Police leadership is inconsistent and, at times, it is frankly inadequate,” Mahmood will say, according to extracts released by her aides. She will say the government will address an earlier failure to invest in future leaders through “the launch of a new fast-stream programme which will place hundreds of talented recruits on a path towards superintendent”.
Between 2023 and 2025, the police inspectorate graded two forces as inadequate, 13 as requiring improving and none as outstanding for leadership. The article also reports that eight serving or former chief constables across the 43 forces in England and Wales were under misconduct investigation. Mahmood will refer to Devon and Cornwall having at one stage paid for three chief constables, two of whom were at one point suspended.
Nick Herbert, co-chair of the leadership commission and a former Tory policing minister, called the fast stream “a significant step towards putting those recommendations into practice”. He said effective leadership was fundamental to improving police performance, cutting crime and keeping the public safe.
David Blunkett, the commission’s other co-chair and a former Labour home secretary, said the fast stream should not be presented separately from the commission’s wider recommendations for changes to leadership competencies and career progression. He said it should not be seen as an elite mechanism, but as an opportunity for people with the ambition and ability to progress faster.
The Home Office said it is considering the commission’s 27 recommendations. They include a national academy of police leadership and increased spending on leadership training; current spending is about £4m in a service costing £19bn a year.
The article says Mahmood will not disclose how many regional forces may be created under the government’s planned changes. The Guardian understands an unpublished review ordered by Mahmood and conducted by Bernard Hogan-Howe recommended as few as nine. Sources say her speech will stress that local policing units would deal with everyday crimes if the changes proceed.
Police leaders have said a lack of money has strained forces. Figures show that early prisoner releases to ease overcrowding since March were followed by a 13% increase in arrests for breach of bail and an 8% increase in arrests to return people to jail, compared with last year. Police estimate the cost to forces will reach £500m by March next year and fear it may rise.
