Somalia’s constitutional overhaul has intensified a dispute over presidential terms, federal authority and elections, after the government rejected a Supreme Court ruling that said new five-year terms could not apply to officials already in office.
On November 4, the presidency removed Chief Justice Bashe Yusuf Ahmed, who was presiding over a case on whether President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud had lawfully extended his term by a year. The presidency cited complaints about the administration of justice. Five judges heard the case the next day and ruled that constitutional amendments extending presidential and parliamentary terms from four to five years could not apply retrospectively. Their mandates, the judges said, had expired.
The government rejected the ruling and immediately swore in a replacement chief justice, setting up a confrontation with the country’s highest court over the end of Mohamud’s mandate and the timing of elections. The dispute is the latest escalation in a two-year contest over the president’s proposed constitutional changes.
The overhaul is intended to address structural problems that have hindered Somalia’s reconstruction. But it has deepened divisions over the country’s political future, federal system and distribution of power. Mohamud and his allies argue that stronger national institutions, clearer rules and direct elections will advance Somalia’s state-building project.
Tensions have extended beyond parliament and political negotiations. Two federal states have suspended cooperation with Mogadishu, while disputes elsewhere have turned violent. In June, clashes between government forces and militias guarding a former president and prime minister brought part of the capital to a standstill for two days.
A federal bargain left unfinished
Somalia’s effort to rebuild a national government has been shaped by decades of civil war. After the central government collapsed in 1991, regional administrations emerged around clan alliances, establishing their own institutions, security forces and revenue streams. Somaliland declared independence in 1991, and Puntland established an autonomous administration in 1998. Other regional administrations emerged in subsequent years and became part of the evolving federal system.
The provisional constitution adopted in 2012 set out a framework for sharing power between Mogadishu and the regions, but deferred some contentious questions about authority and control of resources. Governance consequently depended on continuing negotiations. Elections required agreements among regional leaders and clan elders, while disputes over power and revenue repeatedly delayed national decisions.
“Control of ports and trade routes, and relationships with foreign governments, gave some considerable independence from Mogadishu,” Jethro Norman, a Somalia expert at the Danish Institute for International Studies, told Al Jazeera.
Norman said Mohamud’s overhaul seeks to give Mogadishu greater legal authority over areas regional administrations have long controlled, though enforcing that authority is another matter. “What you’re seeing is the federal system crystallising into two camps,” he told Al Jazeera. “You have Villa Somalia presenting the constitution as completing the state: one person, one vote, multi-party politics, democracy, central federal control over foreign relations and national security, and so on.”
Puntland and Jubaland view the changes as an imposition that undermines the original federal bargain. “Their view is that the 2012 constitution was a bargain between the centre and the regions, and it can’t just be re-written through a parliamentary majority in Mogadishu when the regions have rejected it,” Norman said.
Some federal states maintain close commercial and security ties with the United Arab Emirates (UAE). Mohamud, who has frosty ties with Abu Dhabi, has accused it of supporting regional leaders in disputes with Mogadishu. In January, his government announced the cancellation of the UAE’s port and security agreements across Somalia. Regional states rejected the decision.
The dispute has added to tensions over the federation’s future. Puntland President Said Abdullahi Deni, whose administration is among Somalia’s most autonomous, has suggested the country may need to reconsider how it holds together. “If a solution is not found for the current debate, Somalis must deliberate and decide on another alternative way to live together,” he warned.
The stakes have also grown with international recognition of Somaliland. Israel became the first United Nations member state to recognise the breakaway northern region at the end of 2025.
Somali academic Afyare Elmi told Al Jazeera that the government was weakening the fragile consensus underpinning the 2012 settlement by pushing through changes it could not enforce in states that opposed them. “This is one of the most dangerous times the Somali political system has faced,” he said. “Somalis are no longer moving in the same direction on the future of the state.”
Completing the constitution
Mohamud helped shape the federal system he is now seeking to overhaul. During his first presidency, from 2012 to 2017, his government took part in negotiations to establish or consolidate several federal member states. After returning to office in 2022, he oversaw the creation of another state and made completing the constitution and introducing direct elections priorities.
The boundaries of some federal states remain disputed. Elmi described the federal system’s formation as haphazard. Parliament passed the first constitutional amendments in 2024 and approved the remaining changes in March 2026, concluding a 14-year review process. The overhaul addresses questions about the division of powers left unsettled in 2012.
The changes give Mogadishu greater authority over revenue collection and sharing, elections, and the conditions under which the federal government can intervene in member states. They provide for citizens to elect members of the federal lower house directly through a national electoral commission, while parliament will continue to choose the president.
Elmi questioned whether Mohamud had ever intended federal member states to exercise significant autonomy from Mogadishu. “Hassan Sheikh always wanted a Mogadishu-centred federal state, with no real federal substance,” he said.
Ali Mohamed Omar, Somalia’s state minister for foreign affairs, told Al Jazeera that the previous system, in which clan elders and delegates selected members of parliament, had left successive governments without the public legitimacy they needed. Retaining parliament’s power to elect the president, rather than introducing a direct presidential vote, was a compromise intended to secure support from some opposition groups, Omar said.
Mohamed Ibrahim Moalimuu, a federal lawmaker who supports the overhaul, described the president’s decision to press ahead as “daring”. Successive governments had tried and failed to complete the constitution, he said, while most Somalis had yet to gain the right to elect their national representatives directly. “Somalia cannot just remain stuck just because the changes made aren’t considered perfect for everyone,” he told Al Jazeera.
For regional presidents and clan elders, the changes threaten to reduce their influence over the selection of lawmakers and weaken their political leverage in negotiations with Mogadishu. Puntland rejected the first amendments in 2024 and withdrew cooperation with the federal government. Jubaland followed after a dispute over electoral legislation. Both states have their own security forces and revenue sources, and their leaders argue that agreements reached without their participation cannot be imposed on them.
Elections and political power
The consequences have been pronounced in South West state, where a dispute over President Abdiaziz Hassan Laftagareen’s re-election in March escalated into a struggle for control of Baidoa, the regional capital. Mogadishu rejected the vote and federal troops ousted him. Since then, forces loyal to Laftagareen have seized several strategic towns around the city and clashed with government troops.
After Laftagareen’s removal, South West held Somalia’s first direct election for a federal state assembly in May. The newly elected lawmakers chose Mohamud ally Sheikh Adan Mohamed Nur Madobe as regional president the following month.
Laftagareen, now in exile in Nairobi alongside senior members of his former administration, told Al Jazeera he intended to return to Baidoa and remove Madobe’s government from power. He said he had repeatedly warned Mohamud against changing the constitution without first building broader consensus among the country’s political elite. “Separating powers between the centre and the regional governments saved and kept Somalia together, and making these changes is driving the country apart,” he said.
Not all federal states oppose Mohamud’s reforms. His allies now lead four of Somalia’s six states, where recent elections have also strengthened his Justice and Solidarity Party. But the outcome in Hirshabelle has prompted resistance in its Hiiraan region, where political leaders and elders say long-standing grievances over political representation remain unresolved. Armed fighters have occupied parts of the regional administration’s offices in Beledweyne.
Moalimuu acknowledged that the recent elections “weren’t totally free and fair”, but argued that giving citizens the opportunity to vote was an important first step.
The electoral commission has scheduled parliamentary elections for April 15, 2027, followed by parliament’s election of the president on May 15. The timetable is based on the new five-year terms, although the Supreme Court ruled that the extension could not apply to officials already in office.
Mohamed Mahmoud Dirie, a spokesperson for the Somali Future Council, a coalition of politicians including former presidents and prime ministers, said the group had rejected Mohamud’s invitation to talks in November. “Our request for a guarantor from the international community for whatever is agreed was rejected, which will make it difficult to ensure that the government holds to its side of the bargain,” Dirie said.
Political divisions are deepening as international support for Somalia’s reconstruction faces growing pressure. The UN political mission, which supported constitutional negotiations, elections and reconciliation efforts, closed in October at the government’s request.
The African Union Support and Stabilization Mission in Somalia (AUSSOM), which supports Somali forces fighting al-Shabab, also faces funding shortages and uncertainty over continued UN logistical support. Uganda has begun withdrawing its bilateral troops and plans to withdraw its AUSSOM contingent by the end of 2027. Humanitarian aid is also shrinking.
“Somalia is going through multiple difficult transitions,” Mahad Wasuge, executive director of the Mogadishu-based think tank Somali Public Agenda, told Al Jazeera. Wasuge said the changes could leave Somalia increasingly exposed at a time when “the trust between elites is low”.
