The Senate Commerce Committee approved FCC nominee Danielle Thumann in a 15-0 vote, with all 15 Republicans voting in favor and all 13 Democrats absent. Committee Chairman Ted Cruz (R-Texas) proceeded with the vote after Democrats said they would stay away to try to prevent a quorum.
“We’re going to be doing our job today, even if the Democrats refuse to show up to do theirs,” Cruz said at the hearing. He said there was “ample precedent” for advancing nominations during a lame-duck session and noted, “Democrats will control the Senate, unfortunately, in January. But today is November 18.”
The vote came amid competing claims over the committee’s quorum rules. Senate Commerce Committee rules state that a quorum for nomination votes requires a “majority of the members, which includes at least one minority member.” A spokesperson for Sen. Maria Cantwell (D-Wash.), the committee’s top Democrat, said that “since 2005, Commerce Committee rules required that a quorum include one member of the minority for official action on bill, resolution, or nomination.”
A Cruz spokesperson said Senate rules allow the nomination to advance to a vote by the full Senate. The spokesperson pointed to provisions in Senate rules that require a majority of committee members to be physically present for a recommendation to be reported, but do not specify that a minority member must attend. The spokesperson described the provision as a “cleansing clause” that prevents “earlier procedural irregularities, such as a violation of a committee rule,” from invalidating a floor vote.
Cantwell’s spokesperson said the committee had operated without rules during Cruz’s chairmanship because he “failed to pass committee rules” for the current session. “Nevertheless, in practice it has operated in line with rules from the last Congress (and this provision, specifically, since 2005), including that a quorum with a member of the minority party must be present for official action on a nomination or legislation. Until today.”
Democrats said they boycotted the vote to protest the addition of a third Republican to the committee while a Democratic seat remains vacant. “All Democratic members of the Commerce, Science and Transportation Committee object to the majority stacking independent commissions with Republicans and rushing nominees through the Committee process in this lame duck session with no Democratic pairs,” Cantwell said.
Cantwell and other committee Democrats had urged Cruz to cancel the vote, citing his 2014 remarks. “As you wrote in 2014, controversial nominees ‘should not be confirmed in the lame duck session of Congress by senators who just lost their seats and are no longer accountable to the voters.’ We agree,” they wrote.
Thumann’s nomination has also drawn scrutiny over her work as a legal adviser to FCC Chairman Brendan Carr. At a hearing last week, she told Sen. Ben Ray Luján (D-N.M.), “I have not worked with the chairman on any media-related issues,” after he asked whether she supported “Chairman Carr’s illegal campaign to remove Jimmy Kimmel from the nation’s airwaves?”
Luján wrote to Cruz that Thumann “misled the Committee and offered false testimony, seriously calling into question her judgment and character and impeding the Committee’s work in determining whether she should be seated on the Commission.” He said records obtained through Freedom of Information Act requests showed she worked on media-related matters, including commitments Skydance made ahead of FCC approval of its merger with Paramount.
The FCC website describes Thumann as senior counsel to Carr on matters before the Wireline Bureau, the Public Safety and Homeland Security Bureau, and the Consumer and Governmental Affairs Bureau. Emails obtained through a public records request by Protect Democracy show some involvement in media-related matters.
In follow-up answers to senators this week, Thumann said her work sometimes includes “reviewing documents or filings in a matter outside of my designated portfolio. However, I did not have any conversations with Paramount, CBS, or Skydance related to the merger.”
Luján also wrote that Thumann “played a role in processing informal complaints related to” alleged news distortion on CBS’s 60 Minutes and “she apparently orchestrated the Commission’s response to consumers regarding the Jimmy Kimmel controversy.” The article says Thumann was a recipient, but not necessarily the orchestrator, of the Kimmel-related emails located in a search of messages.
The emails show Thumann approved language for an FCC response to complaints about alleged news distortion in a 60 Minutes interview with Kamala Harris. The response directed complainants to submit comments to an FCC docket established for the proceeding. “Hi Kristi, I have confirmed with the Chairman and Erin that we would like for complainants to be encouraged to resubmit their news distortion complaints in the relevant ECFS [Electronic Comment Filing System] proceeding,” Thumann wrote. “Can you please work on some draft language to send to consumers that would advise them on this step (including how to use ECFS)?”
Thumann has been referred to as Thumann Severs during the nomination process, but uses the name Thumann. If the Senate confirms her, Republicans would have a 3-1 majority on the FCC. The sole Democrat, Anna Gomez, would have to leave at the end of 2027 if Trump does not nominate her for another term.
Cruz said FCC nominations do not have to be paired with nominees from both parties, despite the tradition of pairing nominations when each party has a vacancy. “There’s nothing that requires the president to nominate in pairs… the law merely says that no more than three of the commissioners may be from the same party,” he said. The Communications Act limits the number of commissioners from one party to the number needed to form a majority.
Democrats called for Thumann’s nomination to be postponed. “There is no mandate for the outgoing majority to rush through a partisan FCC nomination in its final weeks… Ms. Thumann Severs’ nomination should be postponed until the next Congress and paired with Commissioner Gomez’s renomination and the nomination of an additional Democratic commissioner,” they wrote to Cruz.
