United Launch Alliance (ULA) said preliminary data suggests the Vulcan rocket’s failure may have originated in the launch vehicle rather than its BE-4 engines. The company has not identified the cause, and the investigation remains in its early stages.

ULA said Tuesday that it lost telemetry and the mission about 10 minutes into the flight. “While we appear to have lost telemetry and the mission at approximately 10 minutes into flight, early indications are that just after liftoff, the launch vehicle experienced low booster performance, resulting in stage separation occurring when the vehicle was low in altitude and below minimal velocity to reach orbit,” the company said.

ULA also confirmed that the Centaur V upper stage and solid rocket boosters performed nominally. The company has not provided details about the reported “low booster performance.”

Two independent sources told Ars that preliminary data points to a problem on the launch vehicle side, possibly involving systems that feed methane and liquid oxygen propellant to the engines. Two sources described the investigation as “incredibly complicated.” ULA and Blue Origin have said only that they are working together to investigate.

ULA engineers are examining whether one of the two BE-4 engines produced lower thrust shortly after liftoff and did not return to full throttle. Video from high-zoom tracking cameras appeared to show one engine slightly dimmer than the other after Vulcan jettisoned its solid rocket boosters nearly two minutes into flight. An asymmetric engine shutdown could also have contributed to the sudden attitude motion shown in ULA’s telemetry-driven real-time animation near stage separation.

The Federal Aviation Administration is overseeing the investigation, which ULA is leading. The information remains preliminary, and no definitive conclusions can be drawn.

The flight was Vulcan’s fifth since its debut in January 2024. Two earlier flights had solid rocket booster nozzle issues, but the rocket compensated for reduced and asymmetric thrust and reached its intended orbit. The second nozzle issue led to a nine-month stand-down.

The latest setback is likely to sideline Vulcan for at least half a year, and probably longer. The US Space Force has national security payloads awaiting launch, while Amazon had more than a dozen launches of its Amazon Leo constellation on Vulcan’s 2027 manifest.

The failure could also affect Blue Origin’s plans to return New Glenn to flight as early as January. Last Tuesday, the company said a modified BE-4 main oxygen valve had completed qualification testing. “Our modified valve has already been incorporated into engines slated for upcoming flights, and we are now rolling it out across the remaining fleet,” the company said. “We expect to complete the anomaly investigation later this month.”

If the Vulcan failure is ultimately attributed to a BE-4 engine problem, it would delay New Glenn’s return to flight. The article says that could also affect NASA, which is counting on the rocket for much of the heavy lifting for its Artemis Program and Moon Base.