The first meeting of Donald Trump, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin as a trio may be unprecedented, but it is not an achievement, according to The Guardian’s editorial. The leaders are due to meet in Shenzhen, China, on Thursday, on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit. The gathering is scheduled to last less than an hour.

The editorial argues that the meeting has no clear agenda and that its spectacle is its substance. It says the gathering reinforces the view that other countries are excluded from decisions, while all three governments are undermining multilateralism.

It says Xi will appear as the power broker bringing Washington and Moscow together and as host in a city showcasing China’s economic and technological progress. For Putin, the meeting could present him as a superpower peer, following his comments about the “humiliation” of Europe. Trump, meanwhile, gains a red carpet reception and another “first” to promote, the editorial says, while the United States has less to celebrate.

The editorial criticises Trump’s approach to longstanding US allies, citing tariffs and a transactional approach to security. It says these policies and his affinity for autocrats have led countries such as the Philippines, which hosted him en route to China, to hedge their bets.

The editorial says Trump is not expected to raise Nvidia and suspected Chinese espionage, or press China over its role in Russia’s war against Ukraine. It also says Ukraine and Taiwan have reason to be anxious about what Trump might say to Putin and Xi, including in bilateral meetings or in an offhand remark.

The article rejects comparisons with the 1945 Yalta summit, saying they overstate the significance of a meeting lasting less than an hour. It notes that China, the United States and Russia have competing interests, including over rare earths and denuclearisation, and says China’s nuclear arsenal remains dwarfed by those of the US and Russia.

The editorial concludes that talks with rivals are not inherently unwise, and that a focused, carefully prepared trilateral meeting on disarmament could be fruitful under another US president. “This is not that world. This will not be that meeting.”