The Trump administration’s request for up to $50 billion to upgrade the nation’s air traffic control system is facing skepticism from senior Republicans, days after a nationwide ground stop left more than a million passengers stranded.
Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy made the urgent funding request over the weekend. Republican lawmakers, including Senate Majority Leader John Thune, are seeking details about how the $12.5 billion Congress approved last year for air traffic control upgrades has been used. Several lawmakers said Congress is unlikely to approve a new request without more information.
“I think it’s highly unlikely that Congress is just going to write a check for $50 billion just because he says so,” GOP Sen. John Cornyn of Texas said. He said a request of that size would require more time for Congress to consider. “When you do things really fast around here, you make mistakes. And that’s why the whole system is designed to move methodically and deliberatively,” Cornyn said.
Congress approved $12.5 billion last year for air traffic control upgrades as part of President Donald Trump’s spending and policy bill. Thune said Monday that about $8 billion remained unspent and that Congress needed explanations about why. He said lawmakers had “attempted to do what we can to ensure that the concerns they have about modernization” are answered.
Some Republicans in leadership are privately frustrated by Duffy’s effort to blame Congress for a funding shortfall, according to multiple sources. Republicans have not ruled out additional funding, but say they want the White House to explain how the existing money has been used before approving another amount.
GOP Sen. Susan Collins, a senior Senate appropriator who said the FAA administrator briefed her over the weekend, said: “What I think a lot of people don’t realize is that the FAA has not spent the money that we previously appropriated — and that part of that money was designated to beautify airports. That should not be the priority. We do have a serious problem with our air traffic control system.” On Duffy’s request, she added: “I don’t see the justification yet for that much.”
Lawmakers also said they do not yet know what caused Friday’s ground stop. Some key lawmakers are scheduled to receive a closed-door briefing Tuesday, and Duffy is expected to meet Senate Republicans over lunch on Capitol Hill, according to a source familiar with the plans. “Well, we gave them $12.5 billion,” GOP Sen. Shelley Moore Capito of West Virginia said when asked about Duffy’s criticism of Congress.
Duffy has said the department lacks money for new telecommunications architecture, software to manage aircraft in the airspace and replacement towers. “I have no money in that $12.5 billion that I can use for a new architecture for telecom. I can’t build new software to manage our airplanes in the airspace because it dates back to the 1990s, but there’s no money for that. There’s no money for towers. Our towers are old,” he said Sunday on CNN’s “State of the Union” with Dana Bash.
A source familiar with the plans said the Department of Transportation has “allocated” all of the $12.5 billion to projects, but funds are not considered “spent” until the projects are installed and operational. Several plans are underway, the source said. Duffy has said the money will be spent by the end of December 2028.
A department fact sheet said Congress set limits on how much could be spent on particular categories, leaving the department without legal flexibility to shift funds between workstreams. It said separate funding is needed for separate efforts, including modernizing air traffic control’s digital architecture and upgrading or replacing aviation infrastructure.
GOP Sen. Rand Paul called for an accounting of the money before Congress considers more. “I think a methodical look at what happened, what mistakes were made, where the money is being spent, before we just immediately throw more money at the problem,” he said. GOP Sen. John Kennedy said he wanted Duffy to explain the need and how the problem would be fixed, including the timeline, responsible parties and cost.
As of June, the FAA had spent $474.9 million of the $12.5 billion Congress appropriated, according to data from a congressional source shared with CNN. The agency had spent none of the $1.9 billion appropriated for a new air traffic control center, the source said. The data also showed that $309 million of $4.75 billion dedicated to telecommunications infrastructure had been spent.
GOP Sen. Tim Sheehy said he wants a closer examination of whether recent outages across the United States are connected. “I want a deeper dive. I think we too quickly dismissed that there was no malicious acts,” he said Monday, citing Microsoft’s outage on Thursday, the air traffic disruption on Friday and bank outages on Monday. “We have very sophisticated digital adversaries. That sounds a little too much of a coincidence to me. So before we dismiss that, I want to see the details on that.”
GOP Sen. Rick Scott of Florida said he wanted more information before deciding whether to support additional funding. “I think we have to get all the facts before we do anything…seeing how they’re going to use it,” he said. “We have to have a budget and what the timeline is, who’s going to do it, all that.”
CNN’s Ellis Kim and Alexandra Skores contributed to this report.
