A survey of 449 U.S. foreign policy leaders found broad support for an active American role in the world, but sharp partisan divisions over President Donald Trump’s policies, including the Iran war and tariffs. The University of Texas at Austin conducted the survey with the Chicago Council on Global Affairs.

The survey included leaders from the executive branch, Congress, think tanks, interest groups, media and academia. The article says their views matter as the United States seeks to end the Iran war and address the effects of tariff policies, and as experts may advise presidential candidates ahead of the 2028 elections.

Overall, 93% of respondents said the United States should take an active part in the world: 83% of Republican experts, 98% of Democrats and 90% of independents. More than 70% of Democrats and more than 80% of Republicans and independents said military power has been very important to U.S. influence. More than 90% across party groups said economic power has been very important.

Views diverged on the Iran war. Among those surveyed, 98% of Democrats and 73% of independent experts said the war was the wrong decision, while 58% of Republican leaders said it was correct. On tariffs, 100% of Democrats and 81% of independents said they were bad for the U.S. economy, while 53% of Republicans said they were good. The article says experts across party groups recognized that tariffs would raise costs for Americans.

The survey also found partisan differences over whether the United States should be feared or admired. Sixty-two percent of Republican leaders said being feared was more important, while 97% of Democrats and 81% of independents said being admired was more important.

Asked whether other countries could resist U.S. coercion, 39% of Republican experts agreed that “Other countries largely have to accept what the U.S. dictates.” No Democrats and 11% of independents agreed. A further 55% of Democrats, 54% of independents and 48% of Republicans said: “Other countries will accept what the U.S. dictates in the short run but will distance themselves from United States order in the longer run.”

For the option “Other countries have viable options in the short and long run to resist U.S. coercion,” support was 44% among Democrats, 35% among independents and 13% among Republicans. The article says the findings point to divisions over the sources of U.S. power and the costs of a coercive approach.

The article describes the Trump administration’s America First agenda as favoring U.S. domestic and economic interests over international agreements and global alliances. It cites tariffs on rivals and traditional allies, interest in acquiring Greenland and Canada, military operations in Venezuela and the war with Iran, and strikes on boats in the Caribbean suspected of running drugs.

The article concludes that the survey points to an opportunity for new ideas and discussion about the U.S. role in the world. It says a future president may need to engage the public more actively on the sources of U.S. influence, and argues that a return to “establishment internationalism of old” is not an option.

The article was written by Joshua Busby, Professor of Public Affairs at The University of Texas at Austin. Busby received funding from the University of Texas-Austin for the project and is a senior nonresident fellow with the Chicago Council on Global Affairs.