Acting US Navy Secretary Hung Cao told a Senate hearing that insurance for a commercial ship crossing the Strait of Hormuz now costs $64m. The figure has not been independently verified and appears unusually high, even by wartime shipping-insurance standards.
Cao made the claim on Tuesday during a Senate Armed Services Committee confirmation hearing, where lawmakers questioned the cost of the war and its impact on freedom of navigation. He first cited $54,000 for a crossing, then clarified that this was the pre-war cost.
The US and Israel launched strikes on Iran on February 28. Iran has since effectively closed the strait to most ships, allowing some vessels through while targeting those it says are unauthorised. Shipping risks have risen, contributing to severe shortages of oil, gas, fertiliser and other products usually transported from Gulf producers through the waterway.
Cao’s $64m estimate differs from other reported figures. In July, S&P Global said war-risk premiums had reached 7.5 to 10 percent of a ship’s hull value, up from 1 to 3 percent, and estimated insurance for a tanker carrying 270,000 metric tonnes of crude could cost about $21m. Reuters reported in September that moving an oil cargo through Hormuz had risen to roughly $10m-$20m, citing an executive at Dubai’s Emirates National Oil Company (ENOC).
Michelle Bockmann, an analyst at maritime intelligence company Windward, told Al Jazeera: “He gave no context. Is he talking about additional premiums for war risk insurance which are set as a percentage of hull value?” She added: “If so, it depends on the vessel type and the rate paid in order to get proper perspective.”
War-risk insurance covers vessels against losses arising from military conflict. Premiums depend on a vessel’s value, its cargo and the likelihood of an attack. Ships face the risk of missiles, drones and naval mines in the strait, and higher insurance costs can feed into freight rates, fuel prices and the cost of goods transported around the world.
The Strait of Hormuz is technically open, but shipping remains well below pre-war levels. The latest weekly report from the United Kingdom Maritime Trade Operations (UKMTO) put traffic about 65 percent below pre-war levels, recording 308 crossings in the seven days ending November 11: 139 outbound and 169 inbound.
US President Donald Trump has said the US Navy is successfully escorting ships through the strait and has suggested the military campaign against Iran is effectively over. Iran, meanwhile, says it controls passage through the waterway and has ordered vessels to use approved routes and coordinate with its forces. Tehran has also announced exemptions for ships from India, China, Iraq and Qatar.
On Monday, UKMTO reported two tanker attacks, including one near Oman that left a vessel disabled with its engine room on fire. The following day, Iranian forces claimed that three additional tankers had struck naval mines. On Tuesday, the US attacked targets on Iran’s Qeshm island, near Hormuz, following an Iranian drone attack targeting US military installations in Bahrain in recent days.
Chris Beauchamp, chief market analyst at IG, told Al Jazeera: “It is only open for business if mariners are prepared to take these risks, and it certainly isn’t open by any pre-war definition of the word.” He added: “It remains a miracle that we have avoided an energy crisis, and the longer this goes on, the more the alternatives will be developed.”
Beauchamp said resolving the crisis would require Washington to recognise limits on its influence in the region. “I can’t see a way that doesn’t involve conceding that the US does not have the ability to order things in the Middle East as it would wish,” he said.
The strait is the only sea route from the Gulf to the Arabian Sea and the open ocean beyond. Before the war, it carried about one-fifth of the world’s oil supplies.
At the hearing, Cao also discussed the strain the war has placed on the US Navy, including prolonged deployments, deteriorating conditions and pressure on military resources. “This war, again, I know it’s a strain on our navy,” he told lawmakers.
Democrats accused Cao of being a Trump “yes man” on the US-Israeli war on Iran and of downplaying its toll on sailors’ mental health after eight suicide attempts on an aircraft carrier. Senator Kirsten Gillibrand, a Democrat from New York, asked him about a sailor who went overboard.
“Senator, that sailor was not trying to kill himself and he admitted that,” Cao told her, saying he used a life preserver. Gillibrand responded: “What was he trying to do? Swim to Guam?” She said: “I think you are minimising what mental health strain is on these service members,” and dismissed Cao’s response as “inhumane”.
