Victoria’s only leaders’ debate of the election campaign gave voters a lively exchange among Labor leader Ben Carroll, Coalition leader Jess Wilson, Greens leader Ellen Sandell and One Nation’s Warren Pickering. In a poll of audience members leaving the Sofitel in Melbourne, 39% said Wilson had won, followed by Sandell on 25%, Pickering on 16% and Carroll on 7%; 13% were undecided.

The “People’s Forum”, hosted by News24 and the Herald Sun, took place two weeks into the official campaign, as early voting was due to open on Wednesday. The contest had been short on excitement, with Labor continuing to slide in the polls and the Coalition focused on avoiding mistakes, the article says.

Wilson mocked Carroll for refusing to name his predecessors Daniel Andrews and Jacinta Allan, saying they were “not Voldemort”. Carroll replied, “I can say their name just as you can say Jeff Kennett’s name.” Wilson immediately answered, “Jeff Kennett.” Carroll did not name Andrews or Allan during the exchange.

Wilson also told Carroll she “would not be lectured” on the costings of her policies after he said Liberal plans did not “stack up” and would require cuts to healthcare funding to reduce debt. “I like to see these scare campaigns that you run,” Wilson said. “But Ben, I won’t be lectured by you or your government on costings when you have racked up $200bn worth of debt in this state.”

Pickering said Victoria resembled “Gotham City” because of rising crime and vowed to imprison more offenders, even if they had to be sent interstate. “I don’t give a damn if our prisons are full. You’ve broken the law. You’re going to jail. They’re bringing in a supermax in New South Wales. That’s where you’re bloody going,” he said.

Greens leader Sandell joined the panel after Carroll and Wilson disagreed over whether Pickering should be invited. She told 100 undecided voters: “Having four of us on the stage tonight tells you everything about how politics is changing.” Sandell criticised Labor over donations from the gambling industry, the Liberals over money from property developers and One Nation over its links to Gina Rinehart, whom she said is “writing [their] policy”.

“If you’re wondering why you can’t afford your groceries or your rent or to buy a home, just look at who is funding these three other parties,” Sandell said. She also challenged Carroll over public-sector cuts and disputes with health workers, teachers, council workers and firefighters over wages.

Sandell said the Greens’ values were “quite far apart” from the Coalition’s when asked if she might support the Liberals through confidence and supply in a hung parliament. “Jess Wilson wants to rip up treaty. She wants to rip up renewable energy. She wants to make significant cuts to public service.”

Wilson said treaty “goes far further than what the voice [to parliament] ever did” and “undermines our parliament”. Sandell replied: “You know that’s not true though, you can’t lie to the Victorian people like that.”

The two also argued over pro-Palestinian protests in Melbourne’s CBD. Sandell defended the right to “peaceful protest”, saying: “There is a very clear difference between antisemitism, which is unacceptable, and actually standing up and calling out war crimes that are happening by the government of Israel.” Wilson said: “At these protests, we have seen people throw rocks at police officers. That is not a peaceful protest.”

Sandell said existing laws addressed such incidents and opposed protest permits. “Politicians shouldn’t be the ones deciding who gets to protest,” she said. “That is an authoritarian government move, and we do not want that.” Pickering also questioned whether permits were the right approach, saying, “I don’t necessarily think the permits are the way to go.” He described One Nation as a “flagbearer” for democratic principles, including freedom of speech.

Wilson held to her position that she was guided by “practicality” and “not ideology” when Pickering pressed her on legislated net zero targets. On the Suburban Rail Loop, she left open the possibility of scrapping the multibillion-dollar project after the Coalition had “visibility” of signed contracts. Asked by moderator Kieran Gilbert whether the Coalition might scrap it and move on, Wilson said: “That’s exactly what the review is for.”

Carroll acknowledged Labor had made mistakes during its 12 years in government but highlighted its record, including 121 new schools, record Naplan results, the highest-paid teachers in the country and 17,000 nurses. He also cited his decision to call a royal commission into allegations of corruption on government construction sites, describing it as one of the “hardest” things he had done.

Victoria will not have another leaders’ debate after Carroll and Wilson failed to agree on terms for one on free-to-air television. The article concludes that many Victorians have stopped listening to the premier.