A planned meeting in Shenzhen between Chinese President Xi Jinping, US President Donald Trump and Russian President Vladimir Putin is being compared by some observers to the 1945 Yalta Conference. Analysts say the comparison is more about optics than substance, while warning that the summit could bolster Putin’s image at home.
Xi will host Trump and Putin on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit. The meeting comes amid global tension and shifts in the international order, but the balance of power differs sharply from Yalta, where the leaders of America, Britain and the Soviet Union met to discuss postwar Europe.
Russia is no longer the Soviet Union, and it remains locked in a battle for control of Ukraine’s eastern Donbas region. Its GDP is similar in size to Italy’s or Spain’s, and the Crimean bridge linking southern Russia and occupied Crimea was taken out overnight in what Russia described as the largest Ukrainian drone attack since the conflict began in 2022.
“Putin's Russia is weaker in all regards — it's not a global economic power,” said Thomas de Waal, a senior fellow at Carnegie Europe. He said Putin’s effort to project Russia as a major power with influence in Africa and the Middle East was “all a bit of a mirage”.
De Waal said Putin aspired to be “Stalin 2.0, sitting down, carving up the world with other great leaders”. The meeting’s likely focus includes nuclear proliferation: the treaty limiting Russian and American nuclear arsenals expired in February, while China has resisted calls to take part in non-proliferation talks, citing the smaller size of its nuclear forces.
Experts do not expect major decisions on nuclear arsenals, but say the summit’s symbolism matters. It would give Putin a photo opportunity with the leaders of the world’s two superpowers and put the United States in the room with two of the world’s largest authoritarian regimes.
Orysia Lutsevych, a Russian expert at Chatham House, called the idea of “Yalta 2.0” “Putin's sick fantasy”. She said the meeting reflected a vision of world affairs led by powerful leaders and could be used for domestic propaganda by each participant.
Ukraine, much of Eastern Europe, the Baltic States, Taiwan and Iran were not invited. Lutsevych said smaller countries and European governments feared their interests could again be subject to decisions by major powers. She said Europe felt betrayed by the United States over its approach to the war in Ukraine.
The war in Iran is also expected to be discussed. Ukraine is unlikely to feature heavily, despite concerns that Trump could discuss ending the war without Kyiv present. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy has repeatedly complained about being excluded from negotiations concerning his country’s future.
The summit follows the first serious US-brokered peace talks between Russia and Ukraine in nine months. American negotiators Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner floated a proposal under which Ukraine would give up the Russian-occupied Donbas region in exchange for NATO membership, according to details made public by Zelenskyy.
Analysts doubt the proposal will hold and say the United States cannot unilaterally approve a new NATO member. Lutsevych said the arrangement would involve Ukraine giving up sovereignty for an agreement from a US administration she said had little respect for multilateral institutions.
The leaders will bring their own priorities to the meeting. It may amount to geopolitical theatre, but experts say Putin could use it domestically to present himself as a player among world powers despite Russia’s reduced influence.