Prof Caroline Mitchell argues that Palantir’s health data system may not be suited to the NHS because it was developed for the US’s fragmented, insurance-based healthcare system rather than Britain’s universal public service.
Mitchell says the news that NHS England may have overstated Palantir’s efficiency benefits will surprise few frontline clinicians. The claim was reported in “NHS England deletes ‘misleading’ claim 137 trusts benefiting from Palantir AI tools”, published on 12 November.
She raises concerns that algorithms used for AI decision-making may be immature in the NHS context because they were developed primarily for a different healthcare system.
Mitchell recounts that a consultant at a local trust described working across seven bolt-on software systems for one consultation, including one focused on billing. A senior US hospital administrator told her that most US health data systems were primarily designed to record care for reimbursement.
By contrast, she says, NHS general practice records are designed to support lifelong patient care and safe prescribing. She adds that the NHS app is focused on coded healthcare, rather than tracking how much of an insurance allowance has been used during the year.
Mitchell also questions why the NHS needs a US company to manage its data, given the UK’s record of healthcare-software innovation. She cites Emis, developed with GP leadership, as having transformed primary care IT decades ago, and argues that software built for an insurance market may not suit universal healthcare systems.
Prof Caroline Mitchell is a GP in Sheffield and professor of general practice research at Keele University.
