The US has asked Ukraine whether it would cede Donetsk province to Russia in exchange for NATO membership, according to the account. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy says no concrete proposal has been put forward and that he would discuss the matter publicly once the US and NATO member states agree on a plan. He said he could not make such a decision “on his own.”
Donetsk and Luhansk make up the Donbas region. Russia controls most of Luhansk province and large areas of Donetsk, while Ukraine still holds major cities there, including Kramatorsk and Sloviansk. Zelenskyy said any potential agreement would proceed “without recognizing Russia's occupation of these territories.”
Zelenskyy said the US was discussing guarantees resembling Articles 4 and 5 of the North Atlantic Treaty, but did not envisage US troops on Ukrainian soil. Article 4 provides for consultations among member states in the event of imminent threats; Article 5 treats an attack on one member as an attack on all. The US has said it is considering bilateral guarantees for Ukraine similar to those established with Israel and certain Middle Eastern countries.
Russia has not commented on the proposals. President Putin's spokesperson Dmitry Peskov said: “we maintain our position that, in the interest of the peace process, it is not appropriate to disclose details of the talks between us and the Americans.”
Experts interviewed by DW are skeptical that a land-for-security deal would work, arguing that the US could not uphold such an arrangement on its own. Oleksandr Kraiev of the North America-Israel Research Program at Ukraine's Ukrainian Prism think tank said at least half of NATO's member states have reservations about Ukraine joining the alliance.
“It seems to me that this is what happens to normal diplomacy when it's been run by real estate agents who are used to selling people something that doesn't really exist,” Kraiev told DW. He warned that the arrangement could become “a second Budapest Memorandum, it'll just carry a different name.”
The 1994 Budapest Memorandum stipulated that Russia, the US and UK respect Ukraine's independence and sovereignty within its existing borders and refrain from threatening or using force to change its territorial integrity. Ukraine, in return, committed to giving up all nuclear weapons. The memorandum did not commit the UK or US to defending Ukraine if it were attacked.
Most experts interviewed by DW oppose holding a referendum on whether Ukraine should hand over full control of Donetsk province in exchange for NATO membership. Oleksandr Khara of Ukraine's Centre for Defence Strategies said ceding territory would violate Ukraine's constitution, harm its national interests and undermine a world order “in which borders cannot be redrawn by force.”
“It doesn't matter whether the citizens of Ukraine vote for or against such a proposal,” Khara told DW, adding that a referendum would set “a very dangerous precedent.”
A survey by the Kyiv International Institute of Sociology (KISS), conducted between October 8 and 16, found that 61% of respondents categorically reject withdrawing troops from Ukrainian-controlled parts of the Donbas, including Kramatorsk and Sloviansk, even in exchange for US and European security guarantees. Another 35% said they would begrudgingly accept a land-for-security deal.
Khara doubts that a bilateral agreement between Ukraine and the US, similar to US arrangements with Israel, would guarantee Kyiv more support than it currently receives. He said such an agreement could cover financial support, joint weapons production and development, and training for Ukrainian troops, “everything that falls below the threshold of collective security.”
“It is good that these commitments — security agreements, political declarations, and the allocation of funds in the budgets of the countries supporting us — are set out in writing, at least for the next five years,” Khara told DW. To prevent another war, he said, Ukraine ideally needs “a nuclear shield,” specifically, a “strategic one from the US” and a “tactical one from Europe.”
Sergiy Solodkyy of Ukraine's New Europe research center said Ukrainian experts proposed an alternative security arrangement to NATO members in December 2023. Under the plan, Ukraine would join the alliance within its internationally recognized borders, with protocols specifying that only territories under Kyiv's control would be defended.
Solodkyy said the arrangement could follow the German example: West Germany joined NATO first, while East Germany joined only after German reunification. “That means we, too, should not give up on our territory or recognize the border,” he told DW, calling the proposed land-for-security deal unacceptable.
“This is a trap that Russia and the US negotiators are trying to lure the Ukrainian side into,” Solodkyy told DW.
